Two months later, she won the Evian Masters by eight shots to become the youngest (18 years, 11 months and 18 days) and fastest (4 months, 27 days) player to reach $1 million in career earnings. She became the first LPGA Tour rookie and youngest player ever to qualify for The Solheim Cup, finishing eighth in the U.S. point standings after only one season in which to earn points.

In 2011 she recorded 10 top 10 finishes including: tied for second at the RR Donnelley LPGA Founders Cup and CME Group Titleholders; tied for third at the Wegmans LPGA Championship and the State Farm Classic; fourth at the Safeway Classic Presented by Coca-Cola; fifth at the Honda LPGA Thailand; tied for fifth at the Sybase Match Play Championship; tied for eighth at the Walmart NW Arkansas Championship; tied for ninth at the Sime Darby LPGA Malaysia and Lorena Ochoa Invitational. Paula also competed in her fourth U.S. Solheim Cup with a record of 3-1-1.

2012 saw Creamer record 7 top 10 finishes which included 3 top 5 and a narrow defeat in a nine hole playoff to Jiyai Shin at the Kingsmill Championship. The consistent former US Open champion made 22 of 23 cuts.