In 2010, Wagner finished 126th on the PGA Tour, just missing full Tour privileges. On February 27, 2011, he won the Mayakoba Golf Classic at Riviera Maya-Cancun in a playoff over Spencer Levin with par on the first hole and regained his Tour card through to 2013. Johnson won the first full-field event of 2012, the Sony Open in Hawaii, and extended his Tour privileges through until 2014. He also moved into the Top 100 in the OWGR for the first time in his career, moving from 198 to 92.